Counterpoint: /r/VintageApple and a lot of reddit usually thinks the sun shines out of its rear end and dislikes its opinions being challenged.
They can be ignored/laughed at as required.
IMHO a lot of the early Core Duo/Core Solo machines are definitely retro at this point. Probably some of the early Core 2's as well at this point.
@Vaneshi @yestergearpc I mean reddit be reddit but it's a place where many (myself included) got their start, not to mention almost 50k users is a not insignificant amount of people. I'd argue it's worth calling them out to change their tone.
Though the fun thing is every time I bang this drum, I do get people agreeing with me (on reddit). The mod team just seems stubborn.
Always keep in mind a very very old 4chan meme when looking at large groups:
"None of us is as dumb as all of us"
Gestalt entities (i.e. "le hive mind") tend to be not very bright, and highly resistant to outside influence/change. Sure they're useful as a source of data but I'd never take one's word as gospel truth.
@yestergearpc I think it’s sadly not helped in the Apple space by /r/VintageApple having a thing in their sidebar saying “don’t post intel products”. Which needs to go, frankly. But the mods don’t seem to want to do it.